| SESSION 1 - MOLECULAR EVOLUTION |
|
Exploring the role of mutation and selection on synonymous variability in metazoan mitochondrial genomes
S. Castellana1, S. Vicario2, G. Donvito3,
C. Saccone4
Synonymous variability in all nuclear protein coding genes of model organisms is somehow
constrained in order to prevent ribosome slowdown during translation, because these could
increase the probability of the incorporation of un-corrected amino acid and consequently
the production of toxic misfolded protein. We investigated how synonymous variability
evolves in mitochondrial genomes of Vertebrata and Insecta in order to
detect events of selective pressures acting on synonymous codons.
At first, we estimated a one-dimensional index of codon usage bias (ENC) for every genes
in the collected genomes (138 insect and 1173 vertebrate ‘RefSeq’ mtDNA), comparing it
with different factors, such as the same index calculated under a mutational scenario. Then,
we compared different codon usage and base composition (on third codon positions)
likelihood models, trying to evaluate if mutation is gene or genome specific and is the only
evolutionary force that determines the codon usage bias.
At last, we collect 45 groups of complete cogeneric vertebrate mtDNAs, for analyzing the
relationship between synonymous and non-synonymous substitution rates (‘dn’,
‘ds’) within each group.
We found that codon usage bias is mainly dependent on mutation (which is gene-specific),
but about 15% of its variability is associated to gene and species factors. Base composition
likelihood models confirmed that mutational input is gene-specific, while the model in which
codon usage is inferred by this input is rejected by the 20 and 40% of insect and vertebrate
species, respectively.
There is no correlation between non-synonymous and synonymous substitution rates among
the protein coding genes in each vertebrate cogeneric dataset. This is in contrast with the
hypothesis of purifying selection acting on nuclear genes.
In the future, we are thinking to improve the modeling of codon usage by taking account the
effect of neighboring base on the mutation bias of synonymous sites.
1 Dipartimento di Genetica e Microbiologia, Università degli Studi di Bari ‘Aldo Moro’, Bari, Italy.
2 Istituto di Tecnologie Biomediche, CNR, sede di Bari, Italy.
3 Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, sede di Bari, Italy.
4 Dipartimento di Biochimica e Biologia Molecolare ‘E.Quagliariello’, Università
degli Studi di Bari ‘Aldo Moro’, Bari, Italy.
| SESSION 1 - MOLECULAR EVOLUTION |
|
Short Interspersed Elements activity, adaptation and genomic distribution in termite genome
A. Luchetti, B. Mantovani 1
Transposable elements (TEs) are self-replicating DNA sequences, widespread in eukaryotic
genomes: jumping across the host genome, TEs interact either positively or negatively with gene
and genome functionalities. Evolutionary models proposed so far to describe the dynamics of
TEs within genomes rely on the so-called “selfish DNA” theory, in an equilibrium between
selection and mobilization capacity.
Moreover, beside the simple TEs accumulation, also their distribution within genomes seems
to be shaped by either selective pressures or local recombination rate. Here, we present the
evolutionary history and genomic distribution of four SINEs (short, non-autonomous elements)
discovered in termite (Insecta, Isoptera) genome through DNA libraries
sequencing and Genbank EST collection scanning.
Two SINEs were found only within the Isopteran lineage, accordingly with age distribution
analysis, while the other two arose before the splitting Blattoidea/Isoptera
(~150 Myr ago). One of them (Taluc) shares a conserved sequence block with other
SINEs isolated in Orthoptera and Diptera, as already observed for some SINEs
in mammals and vertebrates. It also exhibits 3’ sequence changes across cockroaches and
termite taxa, suggesting a retropositional adaptation in different genomic contexts.
Flanking region annotation showed a preferential insertion of the four SINEs in non-coding
region, with significant links to microsatellite loci. In the DNA random clone library, the older
element (Talud) is more frequently found near coding regions with respect to the other
three elements. This genomic distribution parallels the one observed for the human SINE Alu,
where a clear explanation for this distribution has not been yet determined. Selective mechanisms
as well as peculiar organismal traits are here proposed to explain the observed biology of termite SINEs.
1 Dip. Biologia Evoluzionistica Sperimentale, Università di Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
| SESSION 1 - MOLECULAR EVOLUTION |
|
Molecular evolution of a gene cluster of female serine proteases involved in post-mating mechanisms of the malaria mosquito Anopheles gambiae
F. Tammaro1, E. Mancini1, F. Baldini2,
D. Rogers3, A. Via4, D. Raimondo4, P.
George5, I. Sharakhov5, A. Tramontano4,
F. Catteruccia2,3, A. Della Torre1
Proteins involved in reproduction evolve rapidly due to positive selection resulting from
intersexual interaction. In Drosophila, rapid evolution driven by positive selection has
been detected in proteases of the female lower reproductive tract (LRT) known to interact
with proteins of the male ejaculate. Similarly, several proteases specifically expressed in the
female LRT of Anopheles gambiae are likely to interact with male accessory gland
products transferred to females upon mating that induce a series of physiological
post-mating responses in females.
Here we report data on the molecular evolution in five members of the A. gambiae
complex (A. gambiae s.s., A. arabiensis, A. quadriannulatus,
A. melas and A. merus) of a clusters of 3 LRT specific genes potentially
involved in post-mating mechanisms. The 3 LRT-specific genes encode serine proteases
that are down-regulated after mating, two of which expressed in the atrium (and likely to
digest the mating plug) and one in the spermatheca. Adaptive evolution was detected in
several codons of the 3 genes and evidences of episodic selection were also found. The high
level of replacement polymorphisms found in all 3 proteases suggests that these duplicated
genes might experience relaxed evolutionary constraints that could be important to rapidly
explore and eventually fix new advantageous variants. Moreover, the structural modeling of
these proteins highlighted important differences in their substrate specificity and allowed to
localize and better evaluate the effects of amino acid replacements in sites evolving under
selective pressures.
Novel approaches will be developed to characterize the proteolytic activity of these proteases
and, thus, to better interpret the observed evolutionary patterns. Elucidating the functional role
of this gene family would in fact allow to understand its importance in the reproductive
success of A. gambiae species, and to eventually improve malaria vector control strategies.
1 ‘Sapienza’ Università di Roma, Dip. Scienze di Sanità Pubblica, Rome, Italy.
2 Universita’ di Perugia, Dip. Medicina Sperimentale e Scienze biochimiche, Perugia, Italy.
3 Imperial College, London, UK.
4 ‘Sapienza’ Università di Roma, Dip. Scienze Biochimiche, Rome, Italy.
5 Dept. of Entomology, Virgina Tech, Blacksburg, USA.
| SESSION 1 - MOLECULAR EVOLUTION |
|
The evolutionary dynamics of plasmids and chromosomes inhabiting the same bacterial cytoplasm
I. Maida, M. Fondi, M.C. Papaleo, E. Perrin, R. Fani 1
Despite the key-role of plasmids in the horizontal spreading of genetic information within the
prokaryotic community, their evolutionary dynamics has been poorly explored. Particularly
interesting from an evolutionary viewpoint is the cross-talk existing between the different DNA
molecules (plasmids and chromosomes) inhabiting the same cytoplasm. In order to shed some
light on this issue, we performed a detailed analysis of the genome of Burkholderia
vietnamiensis G4, a β-proteobacterium belonging to the Burkholderia genus.
We focused the attention on this micro-organism since its genome consisted of five plasmids
and three chromosomes of different size; hence, strain G4 can be considered as a model
microorganism to analyze the molecular mechanisms responsible of the gene rearrangements
occurring between different DNA molecules of the same cell. To this purpose, we adopted
the pipeline Blast2Network (B2N). This software allows the visualization of evolutionary
relationships among a datasets of sequences through the building up of identity-based
similarity networks.
The aims of our work were: i) the identification and the analysis of the possible evolutionary
relationships existing within and among the five B. vietnamiensis G4 plasmids at both
intra- and intermolecular level, ii) the analysis of the gene flow (if any) existing between the
chromosomes and plasmids of different size inhabiting the same cytoplasm.
Data obtained revealed: i) the existence of intra-molecular rearrangements mainly due to
duplication events that occurred in different stages of plasmids evolution; ii) an
extensive gene flow between both different plasmids and plasmids and chromosomes; iii)
these genetic rearrangements involved single genes, multiple genes, operons and/or gene
clusters; iv) as might be expected, mobile genetic elements have played and are
still playing a key-role in the recombination events occurring between different molecules; v)
complex evolutionary pathways leading to the structure of the G4 plasmids.
1 Laboratory of Microbial and Molecular Evolution, Department of Evolutionary
Biology, University of Florence, Firenze, Italy.
| SESSION 1 - MOLECULAR EVOLUTION |
|
A survey of mitochondrial evolution in Metazoa: large variability in little genomes
R. Lupi, C. Gissi 1
The animal mitochondrial genome (mtDNA) has been traditionally used as molecular marker
for phylogenetic reconstructions but the study of the evolutionary history of this small genome
can also help to unravel the hidden link between structural and functional genomic features.
In this respect, the animal mtDNA can be regarded as a model in comparative genomics,
whose use is also enhanced by the availability of complete sequences for about 2000 species.
In spite of the biased taxon sampling, the analysis of the present mtDNA dataset is doubtless
promising to reconstruct the evolutionary history of this entire genome in a wide phylogenetic
range and to identify possible differences in its evolutionary trend among different lineages.
In order to carefully analyze the plethora of available mt sequences of Metazoa, we have
developed a specialized mtDNA database, MitoZoa, collecting (nearly) complete mtDNA
entries whose annotations have been significantly corrected/improved using a semi-automatic
reannotation pipeline. MitoZoa has been designed both to address comparative analyses of
genomic features, such as gene order, non-coding regions and gene content, and to help
comparisons at short evolutionary distances, such as in congeneric species. Here, we will
briefly present the MitoZoa database and the preliminary results of our investigation on the
mtDNA evolutionary dynamics in Metazoa: we have investigated the variability of basic
mitogenomic features, such as gene content, gene compactness, and base composition,
and the trend of gene order rearrangements in the main metazoan lineages.
In fast-evolving lineages, the same features have also been investigated in congeneric species,
i.e. in closely-related species where saturation of evolutionary changes is unlikely to occur.
Our data show that the mtDNA plasticity of Metazoa is higher than previously thought and
that the mt evolutionary trend has changed several times, and sometimes dramatically, in
the metazoan phylogenetic tree.
1 Dipartimento di Scienze Biomolecolari e Biotecnologie, Università degli
Studi di Milano, Milano, Italy.
| SESSION 1 - MOLECULAR EVOLUTION |
|
Mithocondrial DNA (mtDNA) temporal variation in wild and domestic pigs from a North-Eastern Italian site
M. Lari1, S. Vai1, M. Romandini2, E.
Rizzi3, G. Corto3, P. Visentini4, G. De
Bellis3, D. Caramelli1, G. Bertorelle5
Ancient DNA analysis of faunal remains is a useful tool to reconstruct past migration
events and different aspects of a domestication process. In the last five years, particular
attention has been addressed using both modern and ancient DNA data to clarify the
complex domestication processes responsible of the transition between the wild board
and the domestic pig (Sus scrofa).
In this study we focused our attention on a single site in Northern Italy, Biarzo Shelter
(Udine). This choice is justified by at least three characteristics of this site. First of all,
Sus scrofa is the most represented species at all stratigraphic levels, with large
number of specimens available. Second, Biarzo Shelter represents the only Northern
Italy site with continuous stratigraphic records of the Pleistocene-Olocene transition.
This continuity provides an opportunity to directly monitor modifications in both
archaeozoological parameters and genetic traits in a ~6000 years time frame from the
Upper Palaeolithic to the Neolithic. Third, the geographic area of the site represents a
likely connection region between the Balkans, Italy, and Central Europe, both for animal
migrations and for cultural exchanges. We selected 28 remains recovered from five
different stratigraphic units assigned to three different archeological contexts (Epigravettian,
Mesolithic and Neolithic). Following standard ancient DNA procedures, we analyzed a
small fragment of the mitochondrial DNA (~80bp) that, despite the short length, has been
showed to be highly informative. Our preliminary results suggest that a variation of the
frequency of different haplotypes occurred through time, possibly related to the early
stages of the pig domestication process.
In addition, we recovered in two Mesolithic samples a sequence motif observed today
only in the Near East and which was previously associated to the Neolithic diffusion
of herding and farming lifestyles.
1 Dept. of Evolutionary Biology, University of Firenze, Firenze, Italy.
2 Dept. of Biology and Evolution, Paleobiology Prehistory and Anthropology Section,
University of Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy.
3 Institute for Biomedical Technologies, National Research Council (ITB – CNR),
Segrate (Milano), Italy.
4 Museo Friulano di Storia Naturale, Udine, Italy.
5 Dept. of Biology and Evolution, University of Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy.
| SESSION 1 - MOLECULAR EVOLUTION |
|
The sexually antagonistic genes of Drosophila melanogaster
P. Innocenti1
When selective pressures differ between males and females, the genes experiencing these
conflicting evolutionary forces are said to be sexually antagonistic. Although the phenotypic
effect of these genes has been documented in both wild and laboratory populations, their
identity, number, and location remains unknown. We used a combination of hemiclonal
analysis and genomics technology (microarrays) to ascertain the existence of intralocus sexual
conflict and to investigate its genetic basis. One hundred hemiclonal lines were established
and assayed for both male and female relative fitness in a replicated design under competitive
conditions. We found significant genetic variation for both male and female relative fitness, as
well as a significant negative genetic correlation between the sexes – thereby confirming the
existence of intralocus sexual conflict.
In order to identify which loci contribute to fitness variation and the sexually antagonistic effect,
we combined data on sex-specific fitness and genome-wide transcript abundance in a quantitative
genetic framework, and identified a group of candidate genes experiencing sexually antagonistic
selection in the adult, which correspond to 8% of Drosophila melanogaster genes.
As predicted, the X chromosome is enriched for these genes, but surprisingly they represent
only a small proportion of the total number of sex-biased transcripts, indicating that the latter
is a poor predictor of sexual antagonism. Furthermore, the majority of genes whose expression
profiles showed a significant relationship with either male or female adult fitness are also
sexually antagonistic. These results provide a first insight into the genetic basis of intralocus
sexual conflict and indicate that genetic variation for fitness is dominated and maintained by
sexual antagonism, potentially neutralizing any indirect genetic benefits of sexual selection.
1 Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden.
| SESSION 1 - MOLECULAR EVOLUTION |
|
The Midichloria mitochondrii genome project
D. Sassera, S. Epis, M. Montagna, F. Commandatore, C. Bandi 1
The hard tick Ixodes ricinus is an arthropod of great importance under a medical and
veterinary point of view, as it can be vector of a number of bacterial, viral and protozoan diseases
(e.g. Lyme disease caused by Borrelia spp.). Furthermore this tick species harbours a
recently described intracellular symbiont: Midichloria mitochondrii. This alphaproteobacterium
is a member of the Rickettsiales, a bacterial order that encompasses pathogens (Rickettsia,
Ehrlichia, Anaplasma), manipulators of the host reproduction (Wolbachia
of arthropods) and also mutualistic symbionts (Wolbachia of nematodes). The
Rickettsiales are considered to be the closest relatives of mitochondria, bearing a resemblance
of the alphaproteobacterial mitochondrial ancestor that entered the protoeukariotic cell two billion
years ago. But M. mitochondrii is not only phylogenetically close to the mitochondrion,
it also presents a unique type of interaction with it.
M. mitochondrii is in fact the only bacterium ever described able to invade the mitochondria
of any metazoan. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) photographs clearly show that M.
mitochondrii not only resides in the cytoplasm of oocytes and of accessory ovarian cells of its
host, but it can also colonize mitochondria. In particular bacteria localize in the intramembrane space,
between the inner and outer membranes of the organelles. TEM images suggest that M.
mitochondrii consumes the mitochondrial matrix and multiplies within the remnants of the organelle,
thus indicating a parasitic relationship with the host. Molecular data, however, indicate a 100%
prevalence of M. mitochondrii in wild-collected females of I. ricinus, which is
usually regarded as a sign of beneficial symbiosis.
The sequencing of the genome is a feasible strategy in order to obtain a better understating of the
biology of this symbiont, of the interaction with the host and with the mitochondria. The unique
localization of M. mitochondrii and the current lack of cell cultures make it challenging to
obtain sufficient quantities of pure bacterial DNA. In order to overcome this challenge, we developed
a specific method, which we hereby describe. A semi-engorged I. ricinus female was
collected and the ovary was extracted. Single oocytes were isolated by micromanipulation, then
grouped in pools of 10-20 and incubated in a slightly hypotonic medium that allowed the formation
of small holes in the cell membrane. The cytoplasms leaking from the holes were collected and
multiple displacement amplification (MDA) was performed in order to obtain micrograms of M.
mitochondrii DNA. MDA products were qPCR tested in order to assess uniform amplification
of the genome. Furthermore the possible presence of contaminating I. ricinus nuclear DNA was
also investigated with qPCR. It was thus possible to select uniformly amplified MDA products that
contained minimal I. ricinus DNA contamination. Two MDA products were subjected to
pyro sequencing by 454 (half titanium run and a quarter GS-FLX paired-ends run) and Sanger
sequencing (500 clones, both ends).
The genome was assembled using Mira assembler, Bambus scafolder, Gap4 for contig viewing and
ad-hoc bioinformatics tools for finishing. Inverse-PCRs were performed to close gaps and
disambiguate repetitive regions. Phylogenomics analyses were performed (MrBayes, PhyML) in
order to assess the exact phylogenetic placement of M. mitochondrii, in particular in
respect to bacteria of the order Rickettsiales and to mitochondria. Results of these
analyses as well as other genome study results (currently in progress) will be presented.
1 Sezione di Patologia Generale e Parassitologia, DIPAV, Facoltà di Veterinaria,
Università degli Studi di Milano, Milano, Italy.
| SESSION 2 - BIODIVERSITY AND EVOLUTION |
|
Origin ad evolution of the modern coral reef fish fauna
F. Santini, G. Carnevale, M.E. Alfaro 1
Coral reefs occupy less than 2% of marine surface, yet about 40% of the approximately 170000
marine fish species live predominantly or exclusively on coral reefs. Earlier studies of tetraodontiform
fishes (puffers, box- and triggerfish) showed that reef-associated fish clades are significantly more
diverse than non reef clades, suggesting that coral reefs have increased fish diversification rates.
Here we test whether reef-association has driven diversification in other fish clades as well using
time-calibrated phylogenies from 28 reef-associated clades. Analysis of diversification rates for
42 groups based upon method of moments estimates (Magallon and Sanderson, 2001), indicates
that reef clades have higher diversification rates than teleost fish as a whole. However we find that
most named reef clades are not significantly more diverse than percomorphs.
We also apply recently developed comparative methods to test for exceptionally rapid or slow
diversification events within reef families and across time periods.
1 Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology University of California
at Los Angeles, Los Angeles, USA.
| SESSION 2 - BIODIVERSITY AND EVOLUTION |
|
Ecogeographical variation in amphibian body size: from patterns to processes
G.F. Ficetola, A. Romano, S. Scali, E. Padoa-Schioppa 1
Ecogeographical variation is the co-variation between biological features and geographical or
ecological features (e.g., latitude, temperature, precipitation). Body size displays intraspecific
ecogeographical variation in many ectotherms, with populations with large body size associated
to particular climates. However, the mechanisms determining such variation in ectothermic vertebrates
are poorly understood. Here we analysed body size variation in two taxa of urodelans: the Italian
crested newt Triturus carnifex and the spectacled salamanders Salamandrina
terdigitata and S. perspicillata.
We used an information-theoretic approach to assess the support of multiple evolutionary and
ecological processes proposed to explain body size variation: heat conservation; endurance to
thermal range, seasonality, starvation resistance, water availability, environmental productivity,
parental investment and evolutionary history. We obtained body size for 2639 newts and 3850
salamanders covering the whole range of the species, and ecogeographical information
on the populations.
Our models included spatial autocorrelation and genetic information, to tease apart spatial and
evolutionary processes. For newts, populations with large body size were associated to cold
climates and areas with high primary productivity; sexual dimorphism increased in cold climates.
Evolutionary history of populations had a significant role but explained little variation.
This suggests that local adaptations (particularly to improve heat balance and optimize parental
investment) and phenotypic plasticity are the most likely drivers of body size variation. Conversely,
for Salamandrina most variation was explained by mortality and deep genetic structuring,
suggesting that body size was mostly determined by ancient evolutionary processes, while recent or
ecological processes had a minor role. Our analysis shows that multiple processes drive body size
variation in amphibians.
The difficulty to find generalities is due to the complexity of ongoing processes; the comparison of
multiple mechanism can allow to understand ecogeographical variation.
1 Università degli Studi di Milano Bicocca, Dipartimento di Scienze dell’Ambiente
e del Territorio, Milano, Italy.
| SESSION 2 - BIODIVERSITY AND EVOLUTION |
|
Barcoding meiofauna: the MoDNA (Morphology and DNA) project on DNA barcoding and phylogeny of Tardigrada
M. Cesari1, T. Marchioro1, R. Guidetti1,
L. Rebecchi1, T. Altiero1, F. Vicente2, Y.
Kiosya3, N. Guil4, O. Lisi5, R. Bertolani1
The MoDNA Project has been undertaken to study the taxonomy and phylogeny of
Tardigrada by joining molecular and morphological approaches. Tardigrades
are important elements of meiofauna from marine, limnic and terrestrial environments, including
hostile-life habitats.
Tardigrade taxonomy is almost exclusively based on morphological descriptions of over 1000
species. Therefore, the DNA barcoding method has been performed, with the aim to add and link
molecular information to the morphological appearance of each individual specimen. The whole
tardigrade must be used for molecular analysis, with consequent difficulties in correlating molecular
sequences and morphology. We have perfected methods which allow to retain individual
morphological information either from the animal before it was used for DNA extraction, or
using an egg shell (when ornamented) as a voucher specimen and extracting DNA from the
corresponding newborn, or using the animal as a voucher specimen and its eggs for DNA
extraction. Combining such morphological information (LM and SEM) with sex ratio and
karyological data, it was possible to obtain a good understanding of different species groups.
First results regard the Paramacrobiotus richtersi group, the Macrobiotus
hufelandi group, several species of the genus Ramazzottius, and the supposedly
widespread Milnesium tardigradum.
For this study a fragment of the mtDNA COI gene was analyzed in more than 200 specimens
sampled in Europe and America, including many type localities. This new approach has allowed
us to barcode 31 species. Some of them can also be distinguished by fine morphological characters,
others by karyological and sex ratio information, others only by very different DNA sequences
(cryptic species).
A phylogenetic analysis using 18S nuclear gene and morphology was also performed on 69
specimens, considering several eutardigrade families.
The presence of four new different superfamilies and of new relationships inside them have been
highlighted. Other collaborations related to this project are in progress.
1 Dipartimento di Biologia, Università di Modena e Reggio Emilia, Italy.
2 Centre for Environmental Biology and Department of Animal Biology, University of
Lisbon, Portugal.
3 Department of Genetics and Cytology, Kharkov National University, Ukraine.
4 Department of Biodiversity and Evolutionary Biology, National Museum of Natural
History (CSIC), Spain.
5 Dipartimento di Biologia Animale “Marcello La Greca”, Università di Catania, Italy.
| SESSION 2 - BIODIVERSITY AND EVOLUTION |
|
A multigenic molecular phylogeny and biogeography of the “Haenydra” lineage (Coleoptera, Hydraenidae, genus Hydraena)
M. Trizzino, P.A. Audisio, G. Antonini, E. Mancini, I. Ribera
Hydraena Kugelann represents the largest genus within the water beetle family Hydraenidae,
with about 650 species widely distributed all over the world and several hundreds not yet described.
In a recent cladistic analysis, based on morphological characters, Hydraena s.l.
was splitted in two subgenera: Hydraenopsis and Hydraena s.str.
Moreover, within Hydraena s.str, some derived and well-supported monophyletic
clades were recognised, and defined as “lineages”. Among them, the “Haenydra”
lineage, previously considered by many authors as a valid genus/subgenus, includes 88 species
distributed exclusively in western Palaearctic, from Portugal to Iran, but absent in North Africa.
According mainly to male genitalia features, “Haenydra” species could be divided
into several species groups and complexes.
The aim of the present work was to investigate the molecular phylogeny of the whole
“Haenydra” lineage using both mitochondrial (COI, 16s rDNA, NAD1, tRNALeu)
and nuclear (18s rDNA, 28s rDNA) markers, in order to clarify the evolutionary relationships
among the different species groups and complexes, and to confirm the phylogenetic position
of the “Haenydra” lineage within the large genus Hydraena.
In fact, although the monophyly of “Haenydra” is generally accepted, hydraenid
specialists have been often discordant about the phylogenetic position of the lineage within
Hydraena, sometimes considering it a basal taxon, sometimes a derived lineage.
Furthermore, molecular clocks were used to investigate the natural history of Hydraena
s.str., and particularly of “Haenydra”.
Preliminarly results well supported the monophyly and the derived phylogenetic position of
the “Haenydra” lineage, that was splitted in two major monophyletic clades: the
H. gracilis and the H. dentipes clades, each one including several sub-clades,
often corresponding to previously defined species groups/complexes. According to our calibration,
the origin of “Haenydra” was estimated to be at ca. 8.3 MY, whereas relevant
geological events such as Messinian salinity crisis and Pleistocene Glacial Cycles have been
pivotal for the great morphologic diversification of the lineage.
| SESSION 2 - BIODIVERSITY AND EVOLUTION |
|
Conservation of Galápagos land iguanas: genetic monitoring and predictions of a long-term program on the island of Santa Cruz
A. Fabiani, S. Rosa, E. Trucchi, C. Marquez, H.L. Snell, H. M. Snell, W.T.
Aguilera, G. Gentile 1
The distribution of the Galápagos land iguanas (Conolophus subcristatus) has been
strongly affected by human activities in the last century. Previously widespread throughout the
whole archipelago, today they inhabit only few islands, with populations often small and isolated.
In this study, we analysed the population genetic structure of land iguanas from Santa Cruz Island
to investigate the genetic implications of a semi-captive conservation program that started in
middle 1970s and is still ongoing.
Nine microsatellites were used to measure the level of genetic variability and to detect potential
evidence of inbreeding and genetic sub-structure.
Furthermore, we used Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC), together with software
packages for coalescent-based simulations, to test a priori hypotheses in different demographic
scenarios. Despite the abrupt reduction in size of the original population, no evidence of inbreeding
was found and the levels of genetic variability found place between those of undisturbed
populations of the archipelago.
Nevertheless, the source and the repatriated populations started differentiating (FST = 0.016)
and genetic sub-structure was found. Following our results and the simulation of possible future
scenarios, we suggest the genetic measures that should be adopted to avoid further genetic
variability depletion and preserve this vulnerable endemic species.
1 Dipartimento di Biologia, Università degli Studi di Roma Tor Vergata, Rome, Italy.
| SESSION 2 - BIODIVERSITY AND EVOLUTION |
|
Molecular tools help resolving a taxonomic enigma: the case of Paradoxornis webbianus and P. alphonsianus (Aves, Paradoxornithidae)
A. Galimberti1, A. Crottini1,2,3, A. Boto4,
L. Serra5, M. Barbuto1, A. Bellati5, S.G.
Baccei1, M. Casiraghi1
Abstract omesso per volontà del primo A.
Breve descrizione dello studio:
Il lavoro indaga se due gruppi di passeracei viventi in Italia dal 1995, nella riserva
naturale della Palude Brabbia (VA), ma di certa provenienza cinese, costituiscano due
specie distinte o due diverse forme della stessa specie.
L'analisi molecolare basata su markers mitocondriali mostra la quasi completa identità
fra i due gruppi. Ciò, unitamente ad altri dati derivanti dallo studio di individui dei
luoghi cinesi di origine della specie, porta alla conclusione che i due gruppi già nei
luoghi di origine erano varianti simpatriche della stessa specie. (G.L.)
1 Università degli Studi di Milano Bicocca, ZooPlantLab, Dipartimento di Biotecnologie
e Bioscienze, Milano, Italy (tgalimba@gmail.com).
2 Zoological Institute, Technical University of Braunschweig, Braunschweig, Germany.
3 Universita’ degli Studi di Milano, Dipartimento di Biologia, Sezione di Zoologia e Citologia,
Milano, Italy.
4 Stazione Ornitologica Palude Brabbia, Sesto Calende (VA), Italy.
5 ISPRA., Ozzano Emilia (BO), Italy.
6 Università degli studi di Pavia, Dipartimento di Biologia Animale, Pavia, Italy.
| SESSION 3 - PHYLOGENESIS |
|
Disentangling the evolutionary history of the Tubifex species complex (Annelida, Clitellata): a comparison between molecular phylogeny and cytogenetics
R. Marotta1,2§, A. Crottini2,3§, C. Fondello2,
E. Raimondi4, M. Ferraguti2
Tubifex Tubifex Muller 1774 is a common species in the Lambro River
(Milano) where it forms complex tubificid-dominated communities. Recently, an integrative
taxonomy approach, using molecular and morphological analyses, brought to the species
status validation of T. blanchardi and revealed the co-existence of several
sympatric cryptic evolutionary lineages.
A cytogenetic approach was used to investigate the evolutionary pattern of species
differentiation in this species complex. Indeed, the analyses of chromosome pattern
and variability can help disentangling the evolutionary processes (e.g.: polyploidy speciation)
that shaped the complex relationships characterizing these taxa. Only few scattered cytogenetic
data were so far available for T. Tubifex, and no data exist for T. blanchardi.
We performed a cytogenetic analysis in parallel with a molecular analysis that allowed for
lineage attribution. About 80 cocoons of T. Tubifex and T. blanchardi
were collected and dissected.
For each cocoon half of the embryos were used for genetic analyses (by sequencing
a fragment of the mitochondrial 16S rRNA gene) and the other half was processed for
the cytogenetic assays. Our preliminary results show that four different euploid chromosome
sets are present across the Tubifex’ 16S rRNA gene phylogeny, as confirmed also
by a FISH assay (with an autologous 18S rDNA molecular probe), and that there are three
genetically differentiated tetraploid taxa.
All analysed T. blanchardi have 50 chromosomes (n=25), whereas the
chromosome number of the analyzed T. Tubifex specimens varies from 75
(triploids), to 100 (tetraploid) and 150 (esaploid), with typically large metacentrics and small
acrocentric chromosome pairs. These results are compatible with the hypothesis that
consecutive polyploidyzation events may have played a creative role in shaping the evolution
of the Tubifex community of the Lambro River.
1 Italian Institute of Technology (IIT), Genova, Italy.
2 Università degli Studi di Milano, Dipartimento di Biologia, Sezione di Zoologia
e Citologia, Milano, Italy.
3 Division of Evolutionary Biology, Zoological Institute, Technical University of
Braunschweig, Braunschweig, Germany.
4 Università degli Studi di Pavia, Dipartimento di Genetica e Microbiologia “A.
Buzzati Traverso”, Pavia, Italy.
§ Both authors equally contributed to this study.
| SESSION 3 - PHYLOGENESIS |
|
Re-framing model choice in phylogeographic Approximate Bayesian Computation
S. Vicario, E. Trucchi, V. Sbordoni 1
Likelihood estimate when comparing complex evolutionary hypotheses, as in phylogeography,
is often an unaffordable mathematical task. Methods that rely on approximate Bayesian
computation (ABC) may constitute a valid alternative in such a situation though user need to
be extremely careful in applying the method and in choosing and comparing the models. We
will focus i) on the possibility of adopting a full-data approach in model-choice without a
tolerance threshold (Full Data Resample) rather than a Local Weighted Regression of a simulated
subset closest to the observed data and ii) on the estimate of the goodness-of-fit of simulated
on the observed data by using a posterior predictive statistics to assess overall models adequacy.
The latter can be used to both evaluate the representativeness of the models in respect of the
observed data and to test the efficiency of the chosen summary statistics.
Efficacy of the two methods targeted to estimate relative posterior of competing hypotheses
was analyzed in different test conditions: the entertained model set include or not the correct
model. Using the same simulated data we show the utility of adequacy to spot when no correct
model is entertained. The Full Data Resample method can be considered a conservative and
extremely accurate approach. The swapping for this high accuracy is a high level of indecision
when the right answer is available. Conversely, the Local Weighted Regression method enhances
the contrast in posterior estimates thus quite always resulting in a decision among competing
scenarios. Being this approach structured in “anyway” finding an answer, it was fenced in a
very high level of errors in our false attribution test. Since in phylogeography the probability to
include the true hypothesis among those tested is very rare, we strongly suggest to use both
methods when testing alternative evolutionary hypotheses.
1 University of Roma Tor Vergata, Roma, Italy.
| SESSION 3 - PHYLOGENESIS |
|
Dating arthropod relationships using soft constrains and phylogenomic datasets: methodological and paleoecological implications
O. Rota-Stabelli1, A. Daley2, D. Pisani1
With a documented fossil record of 520 my and more than a million living species, arthropods
are the most abundant group of animals on earth, accounting for 80% of the metazoan biodiversity.
Still, knowledge of their relationships is source of vigorous debate and their exemplar radiation
is mainly unexplored by molecules, in particular by long phylogenomic datasets. Here we use
three distinct large phylogenomic and mitogenomic datasets of up to 198 genes and 80 species
to reconstruct and date the relationships within the arthropod and among their ecdysozoan outgroup.
We show that these three datasets agree in supporting morphologically recognised groups such
as Pancrustacea, Mandibulata and Chelicerata, while relationships among (pan)crustacean
classes are disputable and in clear discordance with those proposed by Regier and colleagues
(2010, Nature). We calibrated our molecules with 30 soft constrains based on fossil records
spanning from the Precambrian to the Cretaceous, and described evolution using the best fitting
replacement and clock models. Results suggest that while the arthropods and their immediate
Onycophora, Tardigrada, Nematoda and Scalidophora outgroups originated in the Ediacaran
or even earlier, radiation of crustaceans major groups occurred in the Cambrian and that of
chelicerates, insects and myriapods in the Orodovician.
From a methodological point of view, most of the estimates varied depending on the type and
length of dataset, suggesting that particular care should be given for the selection of molecular
marker and that the ideal approach should be to cross-test clock studies with more than one
marker. From a paleontological perspective, our results imply that extant crustacean classes
appeared at the end of the Cambrian explosion. Crustaceans radiation overlaps with the
beginning of trilobites decay, suggesting an ecological displacement of the latter by crustaceans.
1 Department of Biology, The National University of Ireland, Maynooth, Ireland.
2 Department of Earth Sciences, Palaeobiology, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden.
| SESSION 3 - PHYLOGENESIS |
|
Phylogenetic representativeness: a new method for evaluating taxon sampling in evolutionary studies
F. Plazzi, R.R. Ferrucci, M. Passamonti 1
Taxon sampling is a key point in phylogenetic studies. Incomplete, biased, or improper taxon
sampling can lead to misleading results in reconstructing phylogenies. Several methods are
available to optimize taxon choice, involving genetic distance evaluations, interruption of long
branches, etc.
However, all are conceived as a posteriori tests, i. e. they can only be carried out after
data collection, when most of the experimental work is already done. We think it would be
very useful to have an a priori test, allowing to compute and predict goodness of taxon
sampling before the phylogenetic work starts. The established taxonomy of the group under
study (although not necessary the “true” one), which is usually available from literature, may
help in this: given a master list of organisms, it is possible to measure to which degree different
subsamples do represent the whole assemblage.
For this reason, we proposed a new method to assess the representativeness of a given taxon
sampling, by developing the Clarke and Warwick statistics on taxonomic distinctness. Our
method aims to measure the phylogenetic representativeness of a given sample or set
of samples, and it is based entirely on the pre-existing available taxonomy of the ingroup.
Moreover, our method also accounts for instability and discordance in systematics: we
conceived a randomization algorithm on master lists, mimicking taxonomic revisions, therefore
addressing test reliability. A Python-based script suite, called PhyRe, was developed to
implement all analyses, and it is available for free download at www.mozoolab.net.
We showed that this method is sensitive and allows direct discrimination between representative
and unrepresentative samples. It is also informative about the addition of taxa to improve taxonomic
coverage of the ingroup. Provided that the investigators’ expertise is mandatory in this field,
phylogenetic representativeness makes up an objective touchstone in planning phylogenetic studies.
1 Università di Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
| SESSION 3 - PHYLOGENESIS |
|
One tree with many dates: assessing the variation of time estimates across different datasets
F. Nardi1
Inference of divergence times, or dating, is becoming a major topic in phylogenetics, and
methodologies and software implementations have been made available that can handle multi-gene
datasets. Nevertheless, while a number of procedures have been devised in phylogenetic tree
construction to test for congruence across datasets prior to concatenation and to test for the
opportunity to combine or partition data, such procedures are not as developed and widely
available in dating analyses.
Here we suggest the use of internal congruence, the rather obvious observation that,
if multiple datasets are applied to estimate dates on the same topology, some will produce similar
date estimates and some will produce more deviant date estimates. We suggest that under the
assumption that single gene datasets are independent estimators of dates along the tree, internal
congruence could provide a workable framework to assess the performance in dating of
a given dataset and to detect outliers.
We introduce a metric to compare how much two trees with identical topology differ in terms
of date estimates and a stepwise exclusion algorithm, derived from an unrelated application in
Real-Time PCR analysis, to rank the datasets from the most to the least internally congruent.
The procedure is applied to full mitochondrial genome data, with four groups (insect orders
Lepidoptera, Diptera, Hymenoptera and Coleoptera) of 14 datasets each (mitochondrial rRNA
genes and PCGs except ATP8). We show, using a randomization test, that there is a rather
unique set of genes that consistently provide more similar, or internally congruent, dates.
A possible use of this rank to select datasets to be used in a multi-dataset analyses aimed at
estimating divergence times is further discussed, as well as its effect over the wideness of
confidence intervals.
1 Dip. Biologia Evolutiva, Università di Siena, Siena, Italy.
| SESSION 3 - PHYLOGENESIS |
|
Assessing molecular divergence time estimates and the placement of alternative calibration points in the primate tree
L. Pozzi, J.A. Hodgson, T.R. Disotell 1
The origins and time of divergence of primates have been difficult to resolve, due to incomplete
sampling of early fossil taxa and to the relatively short window of time in which major lineages
diverged from each other. The main source of contention is related to the discordance between
molecular and fossil estimates: while no putative crown primate fossils date older than 55Ma,
most molecule-based estimates extended the origins of crown primates well before the
Cretaceous–Tertiary (K-T) boundary, with estimates up to 90Ma. While a clear understanding
of the morphological radiation of clade is affected by the completeness of the fossil record and
the identification of clear synapomorphies, molecular estimates can be biased by several sources
of error, including heterogeneity in molecular rates and the use of potentially erroneous
fossil calibrations.
We present molecular dating analyses for primates using complete mitochondrial genomes
for 60 primate species and 40 species within mammals. We apply an uncorrelated relaxed-clock
analysis that accommodates for heterogeneity in rates of evolution across different branches
and takes into account uncertainties in phylogenetic relationships and the fossil record. We
explore the effects of 18 calibration points chosen across mammals on the divergence-time
estimates for major clades within the primate tree by using a cross-validation method that
identifies inconsistent fossils when multiple fossil calibrations are available for a clade.
In contrast with previous mitogenomic studies, our results support primate monophyly and
the position of tarsiers as sister group of Anthropoidea, with the exclusion of flying lemurs.
Our dating results support a long fuse model of evolution, with an origin in the Late Cretaceous,
and the radiation of all major lineages in the early Tertiary. Our study shows the utility of fossil
concordance analyses to critically assess calibration points to be used in estimating divergence
times within primates.
1 New York University, New York, USA.
| SESSION 3 - PHYLOGENESIS |
|
Population structure and gene flow of European landraces of the common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L. )
S.A. Angioi1, D. Rau1, G. Attene1,
L. Nanni2, E. Bellucci2, G. Logozzo3, V.
Negri4, P.L. Spagnoletti Zeuli3, R. Papa2
The pathways of dissemination of common bean into and across Europe were very complex,
with a number of introductions from Americas that were combined with direct exchanges
between European and other Mediterranean countries. We analyzed a large collection of
European landraces of P. vulgaris with six chloroplast microsatellite (cpSSR) loci and
two unlinked nuclear loci (for phaseolin types and Pv-Shatterproof1). We compared
the genetic structure and the level of diversity of this collection with a group of American
individuals representative of the Andean and Mesoamerican gene pools.
The results show that the majority of the European common bean landraces are of Andean
origin. Moreover, bottleneck due to the introduction of P. vulgaris into the Old
World, was very weak for chloroplast analysis but of greater intensity for nuclear analysis.
Finally, a relatively high proportion of the European bean germplasm has derived from
hybridization between the Andean and Mesoamerican gene pools. Based on the analysis of
the distribution of genetic diversity and hybrid individuals across European countries, we
suggest that the entire European continent can be regarded as a secondary diversification
centre for P. vulgaris. Lastly, we outline the relevance of these inter-gene-pool
hybrids for plant breeding.
1 Dipartimento di Scienze Agronomiche e Genetica Vegetale Agraria, Università degli
Studi di Sassari, Sassari, Italy.
2 Dipartimento di Scienze Ambientali e delle Produzioni Vegetali, Università Politecnica
delle Marche, Ancona, Italy.
3 Dipartimento di Biologia, Difesa e Biotecnologie Agro-Forestali, Università degli Studi
della Basilicata, Potenza, Italy.
4 Dipartimento di Biologia Applicata, Università degli Studi di Perugia, Perugia, Italy.
| SESSION 3 - PHYLOGENESIS |
|
The origin of retinal binding domain. A phylogenomics investigation of the origin of vision in Metazoa
R. Feuda, S. Hamilton, S.J. Longhorn, J.O. McInerney, D. Pisani 1
Vision in animals is mediated by opsins, transmembrane G-protein coupled receptors (GPCR)
which are able to react in the presence of light and promote a signaling cascade in the cell.
Animals possess two main classes of visual opsin: protosomes (most of the invertebrates) use
R-opsin, while vertebrates use C-opsins; additionally, most animals also posses RGR opsins
which increase the efficiency of the visual process. Opsins are also known in Cnidara (jellyfishes
and corals) but it is not clear whether cnidarian opsins represent C-, R-, or a third, unrelated
opsin class. More precisely, cnidarian Opsins have been suggested as the sister group of a
clade composed by the R and the RGR opsins, to include both C- and R- opsins, or as the
sister group of all the other animal Opsins (R-, C-, and RGR).
Reconstructing a correct opsin phylogeny is key to understand the origin of animal vision, as
uncertainty about the topology has significantly hampered our comprehension of the molecular
and system processes underlying the origin of light sensitivity and vision in animals.
We used three non-bilaterian animals (two Cnidarians, and one Placozoan) and all the available
bilaterian genomes (both vertebrates and invertebrates) to investigate opsin evolution, and
evaluate whether we could clarify the relationships among the opsin classes, with special reference
to the cnidarian opsins. In addition, we investigated the presence of opsin-like sequences
in Placozoa (the sister group of Cnidaria plus Bilateria).
We show that the cnidarian opsins are either R-, or C-opsins, and that early opsin evolution most
likely involved two gene duplications and one loss. Furthermore we found that the closest outgroup
of the opsins is an ophan GPCR family found only in Nematostella and Tricloplax.
1 Bioinformatics Unit, Biology Department National Universtiy of Ireland Maynooth, Ireland.
| SESSION 4 - ORGANISM EVOLUTION |
|
Comparative neuroanatomy of ascidian and amphioxus larvae: inferences on the nervous system of the chordate ancestor
R. Pennati1, S. Candiani2, G. Zega1,
F. De Bernardi1, M. Pestarino2
Tunicates and Cephalochordates are invertebrate chordates and occupy key phylogenetic
positions to understand the evolution of chordate characters. They are exclusively marine,
the adults are filter-feeding animals and develop through a lecitotrofic swimming larva. Their
larvae display typical chordate central nervous systems, consisting of a dorsal neural tube,
which develops from a neural plate.
Although the gross neuroanatomy of protochordate larvae have been extensively studied
by conventional analysis, we used molecular tools to dissect the fine details of nervous system
components in the larvae of the ascidian Ciona intestinalis and of the lancelet
Branchiostoma floridae.
During differentiation, neurons acquire an important phenotypic character given by the
neurotransmitter that is released to excite or inhibit the target cells.
We analyzed the differentiation of serotonergic, GABAergic, cholinergic, dopaminergic,
glutamatergic and glycinergic neurons in the central nervous systems of our animal models
by studying the expression pattern of neurotransmitter synthesis genes. Moreover, we
localized some metabotropic receptors of serotonin, GABA and acetylcholine to get a more
complete framework of the functional organization of neural networks. We obtained two
maps of the distribution of the main neurotransmitters that allowed us to compare the basic
functional organization of the nervous system among chordates.
We noted that some functional regions are conserved among the CNS of ascidian larva and
that of cephalochordates and vertebrates, thus revealing features shared by all chordates that
possibly could be already present in their last common ancestor.
1 Department of Biology. University of Milano, Milano, Italy.
2 Department of Biology. University of Genova, Genova, Italy.
| SESSION 4 - ORGANISM EVOLUTION |
|
Dormancy strategies in tardigrades: evolutionary aspects and ecological meanings
R. Guidetti, T. Altiero, R. Bertolani, L. Rebecchi 1
Dormancy includes any form of resting stage, regardless of cues required for induction or
termination. It involves a temporary suspension of active life, a reduced or suspended metabolism
and a developmental standstill. One of the few phyla including species able to suspend the
metabolism in any stage of the life cycle performing the extreme form of dormancy (cryptobiosis)
is represented by tardigrades.
Tardigrades are aquatic animals distributed all over the world in many water and terrestrial
environments, frequently inhabiting unpredictable (e.g. mosses, lichens, etc.) or hostile-life habitats
(e.g. deserts, polar regions, etc.). Dormancy includes any form of resting stage, regardless of cues
required for their induction or termination. It involves a temporary suspension of active life, a
reduced or suspended metabolism and a developmental standstill. Dormancy in tardigrades is
characterized by a wide variety of adaptive strategies . This unequalled diversity of strategies is
represented by anhydrobiosis, cryobiosis, anoxybiosis, osmobiosis, encystment, cyclomorphosis
and resting eggs.
These dormancy forms evolved to withstand a wide range of unfavorable environmental conditions
and can be grouped into quiescence and diapause according to their inducing factors, performing
process, duration, and of course, adaptive meanings. The evolution of tardigrade dormancy
strategies received little attention though it had a strong impact on their life cycle, ecology and evolution.
A comparative analysis of the tardigrade resting stages will be performed focusing our attention
to their evolution and ecological meaning.
1 Department of Biology, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, Italy.
| SESSION 4 - ORGANISM EVOLUTION |
|
The mitochondrial bottleneck: strict sex-specific mtDNA segregation in the germline of the DUI species Venerupis philippinarum (Bivalvia Veneridae)
F. Ghiselli, L. Milani, M. Passamonti 1
Doubly Uniparental Inheritance (DUI) is one of the most striking exceptions to the common rule
of Strict Maternal Inheritance (SMI) of metazoan mitochondria and has been found in several
bivalve species. In DUI, two mitochondrial genomes are present, showing different transmission
routes, one through eggs (F-Type), the other through sperm (M-Type). Moreover, M- and
F-Types experience peculiar tissue distributions, with males being heteroplasmic in their soma,
while females usually not.
We performed a Real-Time Multiplex qPCR analysis on the Manila clam Venerupis
philippinarum to quantify M- and F-Types in somatic tissues, gonads and gametes, as well
as mtDNA duplication rates during early embryo development. In most male somatic tissues, the
MType is largely predominant; something similar is found for a few females too, actually showing
MmtDNAs in their soma.
On the contrary, in the germline we evidenced a strict sex-specific mtDNA segregation, since both
sperm and eggs do carry exclusively M- and F-Type respectively. Because of this, we propose
that the sex-specific mtDNA transmission is achieved through a 3-checkpoint process. The
cytological mechanisms of male mitochondria segregation in males and degradation in females
during the early embryo development (that we named checkpoints #1 and #2) are already
known for DUI species; we propose for the first time, a third checkpoint that would act when
Primordial Germ Cells (PGCs) are first formed and would work for both mtDNAs. DUI
provides a privileged point of view to unveil the processes by which mitochondria enter the
germline (i.e. the “mitochondrial bottleneck”) and the evidences we observed on a strict selection
of sex-specific mtDNAs in the germline could be a first step in that direction. Actually, a sound
working hypothesis is that these processes might be based on similar molecular mechanisms
in SMI species.
1 Dipartimento di Biologia Evoluzionistica Sperimentale, Università di Bologna,
Bologna, Italy.
| SESSION 4 - ORGANISM EVOLUTION |
|
The early emergence of a central nervous system in basal metazoans
A. Dell’Anna1, G. Zega1, S. Piraino2,
C. Di Benedetto3, A. Leone4, X. Bailly5,
P. Pagliara2, R. Pennati1
A shared feature of cnidarian and bilaterian animals is the presence of a nervous system composed
of interconnected neural cells. The number of neural cells, the complexity of their connectivity, and
their organization into regionalized neural assemblies show a great deal of variation in all animal
groups. The evolutionary origin of this neuroanatomical complexity and diversity in eumetazoan
nervous systems represents a fundamental problem in neurobiology. Recently, a number of
comparative developmental and genetic analyses suggested that the diversity of nervous systems
of protostomes and deuterostomes arose from a common evolutionary origin (Lichtneckert and
Reichert, 2005; Denes et al., 2007; Arendt et al., 2008; Lichtneckert and Reichert 2008) and that
the urbilaterian nervous system was already a remarkably complex centralized structure
(De Robertis, 2008).
To shed light on this question, we analyzed and compared the nervous system of the larva of the
cnidarian Clava multicornis and of the acoel Symsagittifera roscofenses since
cnidarians are now regarded as early bilateral animals whereas acoels as the basalmost triploblastic
metazoans (Baguña et al 2008). Immunohistological analysis showed that the nervous system of the
cnidarian planula larva possesses a surprising high level of histological and functional organization
with a strikingly large and ordered array of sensory cells located at the anterior pole. Conversely
the nervous system of the acoel exhibits a stereotypical organization and is formed by six longitudinal
neurite bundles and an anterior concentration of sensory cells.
Our observations suggest that cephalization and the potential to differentiate a centralized nervous
system early occurred at the dawn of Bilateria radiation in the last common ancestor of cnidarians
and acoels. Further steps of nervous system evolution could have been the acquisition of a stereotypical
organization of the nervous elements linked to evolution of unidirectional synapses.
1 Università di Milano, Dip. Biologia, Sezione Biologia Riproduttiva e Funzionale, Milano, Italy.
2 Università del Salento, DISTEBA, Lecce, Italy.
3 Università di Milano, Dip. Biologia, Sezione Zoologia e Citologia, Milano, Italy.
4 CNR-ISPA, Lecce, Italy.
5 Station Biologique de Roscof, France.
| SESSION 4 - ORGANISM EVOLUTION |
|
Evolutionary relationships between Zootoca vivipara subspecies as inferred from patterns of genetic variation in Alpine populations
L. Cornetti1
Transition from oviparous to viviparous reproductive modality, which is likely to have a pronounced
effect on the reproductive success and the fitness of the organisms concerned, is a relevant evolutionary
event. Squamate reptiles are of particular interest for studying this shift as it has been shown that
viviparity has evolved from oviparity far more often in squamate reptiles than in all other lineages
of vertebrates.
The lacertid lizard Zootoca vivipara is one of the few squamate species with both
oviparous and viviparous populations. In most of the range, from the British Isles and central France
into Scandinavia and eastern Russia, populations are viviparous, whereas two distinct, allopatric
oviparous populations are restricted to the southern margin of the range.
The ‘western oviparous group’, recently ascribed to subspecies Z. vivipara louislantzi,
is found in southern France and northern Spain, while the ‘eastern oviparous group’, corresponding
to the subspecies Z. vivipara carniolica is located in northern Italy, southern Austria,
Slovenia and Croatia. The presence of Z. vivipara vivipara and Z. vivipara
carniolica in Central and Eastern Alps makes this region an interesting area to investigate
about taxonomical and ecological distribution of these two morphologically undistinguishable subspecies.
We collected a small amount of tissue tail of 193 samples of Zootoca vivipara sp.in Central
and Eastern Alps. We analysed cytb gene (mtDNA), a nuclear gene (c-Mos, oocyte maturation
factor, maybe related to reproductive modality) and nine nuclear microsatellites.
This study allowed us to describe taxonomical and ecological distribution of the two subspecies
in Central and Eastern Alps along with their evolutionary relationships. We analysed genetic variation
between subspecies, within each subspecies and population structure within subspecies.
All these data concur to gain insights about the evolutionary shift from oviparity to viviparity.
1 Fondazione Edmund Mach.
| SESSION 4 - ORGANISM EVOLUTION |
|
Origin and domestication of the common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.)
E. Bitocchi1, E. Bellucci 1, D. Goretti1,
S. Angioi2, F. Desiderio1, M. Rossi1, G.
Logozzo 3, L. Nanni1, D. Rau2, V.
Negri4, P. Spagnoletti Zeuli3, G. Attene2,
R. Papa1
Phaseolus vulgaris is characterised by two geographic gene pools, one located in
Mesoamerica and the second in the southern Andes, with parallel geographic structures in
their wild and domesticated beans. In the 1980s, a wild P. vulgaris population was
discovered in Ecuador and northern Peru, which was described as a new distinct wild gene
pool. This population was suggested to be the ancestral populations of the common bean
on the basis of sequence studies of the genes coding for phaseolin, the main seed-storage
protein. The occurrence of independent domestication events in Mesoamerica and the Andes
is well established; however, the number of domestication events that occurred in the two
different regions remains a topic of discussion.
We have carried out various studies using multilocus molecular markers with the wild and
domesticated genotypes of the common bean, including an analysis of the structure of the
European landraces. Recently, we analysed a representative panel containing both wild and
domesticated P. vulgaris (215 accessions overall) at the nucleotide diversity level,
for five independent genes. Moreover, we analysed the effects of domestication in Mesoamerica
on the nucleotide diversity of 48 loci.
Here, we present a summary of the results obtained from these studies, with particular focus
on the origin of the species and the effects of domestication on the common bean genome.
Our data indicate a new scenario for the structure and evolution of wild P. vulgaris,
especially questioning the Peru-Ecuador origin, and arguing in favour of a Mesoamerican
origin of the species. Moreover, the data support the occurrence of a single domestication
event in Mesoamerica, and they also tend to support the same scenario in the Andes.
1 Dipartimento di Scienze Ambientali e delle Produzioni Vegetali (SAPROV),
Università Politecnica delle Marche, Ancona, Italy.
2 Dipartimento di Scienze Agronomiche e Genetica Vegetale Agraria, Università
degli Studi di Sassari, Sassari, Italy.
3 Dipartimento di Biologia Difesa e Biotecnologie Agro-forestali, Università degli
Studi della Basilicata, Potenza, Italy.
4 Dipartimento di Biologia Vegetale e Biotecnologie Agro-ambientali e Zootecniche,
Università degli Studi di Perugia, Perugia, Italy.
| SESSION 4 - ORGANISM EVOLUTION |
|
Pristionchus uniformis, should I stay or should I go. Host switching in a nematode
I. D'Anna1
Pristionchus pacificus is an established model system in evolutionary and developmental
biology. Studies of other Pristionchus species, such as the closely related gonochoristic
Pristionchus uniformis, can help us gain a comprehensive understanding of the hermaphroditic
P. pacificus. Nematodes of the genus Pristionchus have a species-specific
necromenic association predominantly with scarab beetle.
One interesting exception is Pristionchus uniformis, one of a few Pristionchus
species that shows host switching. In particular, P. uniformis is observed in both the
chrysomelid Leptinotarsa decemlineata (Colorado potato beetle), and scarab beetles.
In this study we provide a first insight into the ecology and genome organization of the species
P. uniformis. Specifically, we present the reconstruction of P. uniformis
chromosomes by generating a genetic linkage map based on 48 nuclear markers, tested on a
meiotic mapping panel of 42 inbred lines. We can show evidence for macrosynteny and are
currently investigating if colinearity is also conserved between P. pacificus
and P. uniformis.
In parallel, we plan to integrate this newly acquired knowledge of the P. uniformis genome
to identify the genetic basis of the unique association between the nematode P. uniformis
and the toxic Colorado potato beetle. Indeed P. uniformis is the only nematode species
that we could isolate from both North America and Western Europe and from both the long
living scarab beetles and the leaf beetle Leptinotarsa decemlineata, which is
characterized by a much shorter life cycle.
We are currently investigating if the absence of other nematodes in the Colorado potato beetle
could be justified by the toxicity in the beetle hemolymph and how P. uniformis has
evolved a resistance to it.
1 Max Planck Institute for Developmental Biology, Department for Evolutionary Biology.
| SESSION 4 - ORGANISM EVOLUTION |
|
DNA barcoding a tool to detect cryptic species? Amblyomma cajennense, a case of study
M. Montagna1, E. Ferri2, L. Beati3,
D. Sassera1, M. Casiraghi2, S. Epis1,
C. Bandi1
The purpose of the Consortium for the Barcode of Life (CBOL) is to obtain a complete molecular
“catalogue of life”. The main goal is to simplify identification of any kind of biological sample, but
also to create a world DNA-sequence bank, purpose that is getting more and more important
every day, considering the rising rates in species extinction. Barcoding means identification of
taxa using a simple molecular approach, consisting of a PCR and subsequent sequencing of the
obtained product. DNA barcoding is also useful to help the detection of cryptic species. The
barcoding approach can be very useful for ticks, as identification of tick samples based on
morphology requires experience and a high level of knowledge of these arthropods, furthermore
most discriminating morphological features are sometimes visible only in adult specimens, making
species identification of immature stages simply impossible in a number of cases.
The main problem with barcoding is being able to correctly evaluate the capability of molecular
markers to discriminate between different species. A molecular marker with high interspecific
variability but high intraspecific identity needs to be used, in order to obtain a “barcoding gap”
necessary to discriminate between different species. The genus Amblyomma comprises
126 species of hard ticks, 57 restricted to Neotropical region, among them there are species
that are thought to mask “cryptic species”. Correct identification of all the species belonging
to this genus of the family Ixodidae is often difficult, in fact through the years there have
been a number of changes in the taxonomic keys for the identification of certain species as well
as in some species names. In order to aid the identification of species of the genus
Amblyomma, here we present the testing of a barcoding approach on 560 samples
from 69 species of the genus Amblyomma with specific attention on comprehensive
sampling strategy of Amblyomma cajennense (106 specimens) from different population
(11 localities) of the area in which the species is distributed.
As suggested by CBOL protocols, our PCR target was a fragment of 610 bp of the mitochondrial
gene cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1 (COI). Amplification of this target in PCR was obtained
with universal primers for diverse metazoan invertebrates LCO1490 and HCO2198. PCR
was successful on all samples, allowing us to perform DNA sequencing and to obtain the
desired 610 bp DNA fragment for all 560 samples. The obtained sequence database was
tested with a specific leave-one-out test, estimating the genetic distance, in order to assess
the presence of the “identity percentage gap” between intra- and inter- specific variation.
The barcoding approach was coherent with the morphological identification of the samples
in most cases, but a few situations of disagreement arose. In details we examined the variability
of COI fragment (610 bp) in Amblyomma cajennense samples and we found that the
intra specific variation of specimens belonging to different populations reach value typical for
inter- specific variation.
1 DIPAV, Sezione di Patologia Generale e Parassitologia, Facoltà di Medicina Veterinaria,
Università degli Studi di Milano, Milano, Italy.
2 Dipartimento di Biotecnologie e Bioscienze, ZooPlantLab, Università degli Studi di Milano
Bicocca, Milano, Italy.
3 U.S. National Tick Collection, IAP-Georgia Southern University, Statesboro, USA.
| SESSION 5 - HUMAN EVOLUTION |
|
Pre-Neolithic signals of population expansion in Bantu speakers detected by high resolution analysis of Y-chromosome lineages
V. Montano1, V. Marcari1, C. Batini4,
G. Berniell-Lee2, O. Anayale3, D. Comas2,
G. Destro-Bisol1
Bantu speaking populations represent a subject of particular interest for linguistics, archaeologists
and molecular anthropologists. While linguistic data suggests that a population expansion driven
by Neolithic revolution (~ 3-5 kya ago) could have been responsible for the spreading of Bantu
languages, from the genetic point of view the effective role of population expansion in the whole
process has not been clarified.
We studied 17 populations from Nigeria, Cameroon, Gabon and Congo, which are thought
to be in continuity with the groups who took part to the “Western stream” of the Bantu expansion.
A total of 505 male individuals were typed for 20 SNPs and 17 STRs of the Y-chromosome.
We detected signals of structure which seem to not follow a global pattern of geographic
distribution according to the analysis of spatial PCs (Jombart et al., 2008). Using Batwing software
(Wilson et al., 2003) under a model of constant population size followed by a demographic
expansion, we estimated a time since expansion of 8 kya from an ancestral population size of
approximately 2800 individuals.
Dividing the dataset with a geographic criterion, more recent estimates of time since expansion
were obtained for Gabonese populations relative to Nigeria and Cameroon (~5.6, ~11.0 and
~9.0 kya, respectively). This was paralleled by a larger ancestral effective population size (~3600
for Gabon vs ~1600 for Nigeria and Cameroon), apparently mirroring the higher genetic variability
in Gabon both at the population and haplogroup level. Accordingly, we suggest that population
expansion events are likely to have occurred in sub Saharan Africa before the Neolithic age.
However, only Gabonese region seems to have undergone strong recent migration processes.
1 Dipartimento di Biologia Ambientale, Università di Roma “La Sapienza”, Rome,
Italy; Istituto Italiano di Antropologia, Rome, Italy.
2 Unitat de Biologia Evolutiva, Department de Ciencies Experimentals i de la Salut,
Universitat “Pompeu Fabra”, Barcelona, Spain.
3 Department of Zoology, Ibadan University, Ibadan, Nigeria.
4 Department of Genetics, University of Leicester, UK.
| SESSION 5 - HUMAN EVOLUTION |
|
Sensory drive of colour signals in humans
F.T. Wehrle1
Sensory drive is a broad concept which assesses the evolutionary dependences of similar animal
behaviours in different contexts. Sensory and behavioural adaptations in an ancestral context
(preexisting bias) are thought to impose selection pressures on new traits emerging in more recent
contexts and thus to “drive” their evolution. These selection pressures may either favour traits that
maximally stimulate the sensory system of the recipient (sensory exploitation) or traits that optimally
match the original stimulus (sensory trap). In Catarrhine primates (old world monkeys, apes and
humans), colour stimuli in the food context are thought to have coevolved with trichromatic colour
vision in a way that signals of good food quality trigger attraction behaviour.
This attraction is thought to impose selection pressure on pelage and skin colouration as signals
for mate choice in the more recent sexual context. This context is particularly important in humans,
who live in large, interdependent social groups and who are known to signal sexually relevant content
like hormonal state or health via changes in skin colouration. With innovative computerised methods
we experimentally assess the selection pressures imposed on colour signals in the food and the
sexual context in humans. Based on our results we discuss the applicability of the sensory drive
models to the evolution of human skin colour signals as well as their limitations.
1 Albert-Ludwigs University Freiburg, Germany.
| SESSION 5 - HUMAN EVOLUTION |
|
No evidence of Neandertal admixture in Cro-Magnoid and modern European mitochondrial genomes
S. Ghirotto, F. Tassi, A. Benazzo, G. Barbujani 1
Neandertals, the archaic human form documented in Eurasia until 29,000 years ago, share no
mitochondrial haplotype with modern Europeans. Whether this means that the two groups were
reproductively isolated is controversial, and indeed nuclear data have been interpreted as suggesting
that they admixed. We explored the range of demographic parameters that may have generated
the observed mitochondrial diversity, simulating 2.5 million genealogies under five evolutionary
models differing as for the relationships among Neandertals, modern Europeans and Cro-Magnoids,
the anatomically modern humans who coexisted with Neandertals for millennia. We compared by
Approximate Bayesian Computation the simulation results with mitochondrial diversity in 7
Neandertal, 3 Cro-Magnoid, and 150 opportunely chosen modern Europeans. A model of
genealogical continuity between Cro-Magnoid and Europeans, with no Neandertal contribution,
received overwhelming support from the analyses.
The maximum degree of Neandertal admixture was estimated at 0.3%, one order of magnitude less
than suggested by studies of the Neandertal nuclear genome. However, results based on nuclear and
mitochondrial data might be reconciled if smaller population sizes led to faster lineage sorting for
mitochondrial DNA, and Neandertals shared a longer period of common ancestry with the
non-African’s than with the African’s ancestors.
1 Dipartimento di Biologia ed Evoluzione, Università di Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy.
| SESSION 5 - HUMAN EVOLUTION |
|
Humans and their environment: the evolution of loci involved in metabolism of exogenous molecules in globally diverse populations
S. Fuselli, P. Maisano Delser 1
Genes involved in biotransformation of exogenous substances are particularly interesting from
the evolutionary point of view because of their role as mediators between the organism and the
environment. The chemical environment varies significantly with diet, climate, lifestyle, etc., and
thus in humans a great deal of inter-ethnic differentiation is expected for these genes.
Here we analyzed the degree of human population differentiation at 614 single nucleotide
polymorphisms (SNPs) in 121 genes coding for biotransformation proteins of exogenous
substances in 52 globally diverse populations from the Human Genome Diversity Panel (HGDP).
To identify the type of genes and genetic variants preferentially targeted by selection, we applied
a statistical approach that considers the degree of population differentiation (Fst) looking for signals
of adaptation enriched in our candidate genes. Under an assumption of neutrality, the geographic
structure of genetic diversity is determined by demographic history which affect all loci similarly.
By contrast, natural selection acts in a locus- specific manner and local positive selection in
particular tends to increase Fst.
The same approach was used to test the hypothesis that the selective regime acting on genes
involved in biotransformation of exogenous molecules changed when human populations shifted
from an economy based hunting and gathering to one in which food was produced by farming and
animal breeding, in the Neolithic period. To this aim we compared present-day HGDP hunting-gathering
populations with geographically close food producers from East Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa.
Our analyses show that, in general, genes involved in biotransformation of exogenous compounds
are not enriched of SNPs showing signals of adaptive evolution, both globally and comparing
hunter-gatherers and food producers. However, specific categories of genes and sites show
patterns indicating that population history alone is not enough to explain the observed genetic
differences between different subsistence economies.
1 Università di Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy.
| SESSION 5 - HUMAN EVOLUTION |
|
Identifying genetic bases of human adaptation to high altitude
C. Chianella, A. Panziera, P. Maisano Delser, S. Fuselli 1
High-altitude is the only environment colonized by modern humans where no behavioral buffering
is available to face the peculiar and unavoidable stress: hypoxia. Life at low oxygen pressure needs
specific biological adaptations to deliver enough oxygen to maintain aerobic metabolism. In the last
decades many studies investigated the relationship between altitude and adaptive phenotypic traits,
but to date no association between genetic variants and adaptive traits to hypoxia-related stress
have been found in native American highlands.
Here we aim at identifying the genetic bases of human adaptation to high altitude by studying the
evolution of candidate genes.
To this goal we (i) identified candidate genes by means of a bioinformatic approach, (ii) studied
their molecular evolution comparing different species and (iii) began to investigate their genetic
variation in Andean native populations.
The transcription factor HIF 1a, a master regulator of O2 homeostasis, and additional 8 loci
encoding for proteins that either regulate HIF1 activity (PHD1,2,3 and VHL) or represent its
targets (NOS3, EDN1, EPO, VEGFA), were selected as candidate genes. Applying phylogenetic
methods for comparative analysis of DNA we found that the candidate genes mostly evolved under
purifying selection, as expected when important metabolic activity is conserved. Few codons were
identified showing signature of adaptive evolution, and may represent good targets for the high
altitude human population study.
We collected DNA and phenotypic measures from individuals of three Andean populations living
at 3000-4000 m. Our re-sequencing analysis of coding and regulatory regions of two candidate
genes, EPO and VHL, showed that these loci are extremely conserved also within humans, the
few polymorphic sites being located in regulatory regions. Further candidate genes re-sequencing
and comparison with low altitude populations from the same geographic regions will allow us to
define a possible adaptive role of the genetic variation identified in our study.
1 Dipartimento di Biologia ed Evoluzione, Università di Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy.
| SESSION 6 - EVOLUTIONARY THEORY |
|
Fitness landscapes and surfaces of selective value
E. Serrelli1
The notion of “fitness landscapes” was presented by Sewall Wright in 1932. Its influence in
evolutionary biology was extensive in several directions up to the present day. One direction
consists in studies that built “fitness landscapes” although, according to my analysis, they employed
only a part of Wright’s ideas - i.e. the one concerning “surfaces of selective value” (cf. Wright
1988) - focusing on one or few genetic or phenotypic traits of the studied systems. The model
Wright fostered in 1932 was about the entire genotypic space of a Mendelian population,
characterized by huge dimensionality.
The lack of formal tools and computational power have prevented its actual construction, but
understanding the original idea and how it differs from the realized models seems useful, all the
most after the recent proposal by Sergey Gavrilets (e.g. Gavrilets 1997; 2004) of revising the
overall structure of the genotype space. Understanding crucial differences is necessary here as
well: for example, the newly proposed diagrams - namely, nearly flat, holey surfaces - do not
represent the whole genotypic space, but the existence and properties of “nearly neutral networks”
within it. The latter are fundamental for building particular speciation models called “spontaneous
clusterization” (Gavrilets 2010).
I will present, on the one hand, Wright’s primal proposal and the revision advanced by Gavrilets,
on the other hand, the fruitful “surface of selective value” method, that consists in (1) representing
genetic or phenotypic variants as points that are distributed on a bi-dimensional surface, so that
the distance between points be proportional to the “reachability” between variants; (2) extruding
such a surface along a third, orthogonal dimension that represents the considered variants’ fitness.
The method aids the study of the role of fitness and other factors in evolutionary dynamics.
1 Università degli Studi di Milano Bicocca, Dipartimento di Scienze Umane
per la Formazione “Riccardo Massa”, Milano, Italy.
| SESSION 6 - EVOLUTIONARY THEORY |
|
Development of a new evolutionary theory
G. Damiani1, E, Capelli2
Many experimental evidences, as for example the distribution of retroelements and DNA mutations
in complex genomes, lead to the discovery of mechanisms based on epigenetic signals, editing of
nucleic acids, reverse transcription, and micro-recombination, that promote DNA changes and
horizontal transfer of genetic information between cells and organisms. The natural genetic
engineering systems are triggered into action by a metabolic shift from an anabolic-syntropic
phase to a catabolic-entropic one. The Lotka-Volterra oscillation between these two alternate
and complementary phases at the levels of molecules, cells, organisms, and populations might
explain many evolutionary dynamics and the emergence of collective behaviours and fractal
structures near the critical points in many physical and biological systems.
In the catabolic phase, the genetic apparatus and the Darwinian processes allow the reproduction
and conservation of biological systems. In the anabolic phase, the epigenetic apparatus and the
Lamarckian processes produce innovative adaptations in response to environmental variations.
In complex animals, the acquired immunity regulates the selective proliferation of the cells with
adaptive mutations during the physiological responses to stresses. The same immunotrophic
process allows the maternal selection of embryos with adaptive mutations and maintains the
metabolic biodiversity of animal populations. A better understanding of how the genetic apparatus
interacts with the environment by means of the epigenetic systems will allow the design of
interventions to reduce the population load of complex diseases.
1 Istituto di Genetica Molecolare, CNR, Pavia, Italy.
2 Dipartimento di Biologia Animale, Università di Pavia, Pavia, Italy
References
The Yin and Yang of anti-Darwinian epigenetics and Darwinian genetics.
Damiani G., Riv Biol. 2007. 100(3):361-402.
Corrections to chance fluctuations: quantum mind in biological evolution?
Damiani G., Riv Biol. 2009. 102(3): 421-448.
| SESSION 6 - EVOLUTIONARY THEORY |
|
Genetic consequence of habitat fragmentation during a range expansion
S. Mona, L. Excofier 1
Habitat fragmentation is often defined as a process where the habitat of a species is broken into
smaller and isolated patches, accompanied (or not) by a loss of the total area available.
Here we investigated the genetic consequences of habitat fragmentation during a range expansion.
Range expansions are known to leave specific footprint on the genetic diversity of a meta-population
both in homogeneous and in some form of heterogeneous environment. Habitat fragmentation can
be considered as the simplest form of environmental heterogeneity, i.e. a mixture of habitat and
non-habitat.
To model habitat fragmentation during a range expansion, we simulated a forward expansion in a
two-dimensional square array of 50x50 demes. The array was partitioned into group of demes
(patches) by adding barrier to dispersal defining 100 patches of 5x5 demes. Demes were allowed
to exchange migrants with the surroundings demes at a rate m1 if belonging to the same
patch and at rate m2 if a barrier is present (with m2 < m1). Demographic
and migration histories were then used to generate genetic diversity in a sample of genes under a
coalescent approach. Sampling was performed at different scales: demes, patches, region (group
of four neighbouring patches) and at the landscape level.
By varying the carrying capacity (k), m and time of the expansion, we found they all exert
a strong influence on the genetic diversity of the meta-population, particularly when sampling within
demes and patches (but not at the region and landscape level). Moreover, we found that genealogies
at all sampling levels depend on k and m separately, rather than on their product.
Finally, we performed additional simulations removing the barriers sometimes after the expansion,
to determine how fast genetic diversity can be restored.
We found that, under many conditions, the process may take a large number of generations.
1 University of Bern, Berna, Svizzera.
| SESSION 6 - EVOLUTIONARY THEORY |
|
"Extended synthesis": a progressive shift of research program
T. Pievani1
The theory of evolution shows a 150 years history of theoretical and empirical extensions and revisions,
without any apparent radical change of “paradigm”. We would like to present here a tentative extension
of the neo-Darwinian structure of evolutionary theory. The ongoing transition from the Modern Synthesis
to a so-called “Extended Synthesis” is interpreted through the Methodology of Scientific Research
Programs, proposed by the epistemologist Imre Lakatos and updated. The current situation in
evolutionary biology is represented by a “progressive” shift of the neo-Darwinian research program,
moving from the quite rigid framework of the Modern Synthesis to the more inclusive and pluralistic
“core” and “protective belt” of the Extended Synthesis. So, we argument against the idea that we
would have now more “theories of evolution” or a new “theory” with post-Darwinian features.
What we actually see at the front of the researches in evolutionary biology is quite different: an extended
and strongly corroborated neo-Darwinian core (with its four main factors: variation and inheritance,
natural selection, genetic drift, migration and macro-evolutionary effects), surrounded by a protective
belt of auxiliary assumptions in progress, concerning i.e. multiple patterns about modes and rhythms
of speciation, levels of selection, the effective agency of natural selection in the genome, the relationships
between evolution and development, epigenetics, phenotypic plasticity, endosymbiosis.
This analysis of the rational and continuous dynamics of growth of biological knowledge seems
much needed also for a critical examination of some popular controversies about evolution.
1 University of Milan - Bicocca, Milano, Italy.